Every steakhouse in New York City. The same order at each place. Ranked.
One steakhouse every two weeks. One Manhattan cocktail, one shrimp cocktail, one filet mignon, one side of creamed spinach, and one slice of New York cheesecake — scored out of 100.
1 steakhouse visited · 84 to go · started July 2026
Latest review
Latest review · Jul 2026
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen · Visit #1 · Read the review →
34/100
The Leaderboard
Average 34/100
84 still to visit. See the map →
Best of each thing
The same five items, everywhere. Here is who is winning each one so far.
Best Manhattan
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
4/10
Best Shrimp Cocktail
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
3/10
Best Filet Mignon
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
11/30
Best Creamed Spinach
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
4/10
Best New York Cheesecake
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
2/5
Best Room
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
4/10
Best Service
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
4/10
Best Extras
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
1/5
Best Value
West Side Steakhouse
Hell's Kitchen
1/10
One steakhouse every two weeks.
Get each review when it publishes. No other email, ever.
Newsletter signup goes live once PUBLIC_NEWSLETTER_ACTION is set in .env.