Skip to content
steakhouses.nyc

The Same Order Index

Because the order never changes, the bill is directly comparable. This is the same Manhattan, shrimp cocktail, filet mignon, creamed spinach and cheesecake at every steakhouse in New York — priced side by side.

Median order
$172

Five items, before tax and tip

Most expensive
$182

Bourbon Steak

Least expensive
$109

West Side Steakhouse

Best value
$1.98/pt

West Side Steakhouse

The identical dinner costs $73 more at the top of this list than at the bottom.

Cost of the order, by steakhouse

Five items, before tax and tip. 5 of 5 visits have prices logged.

Item by item

SteakhouseManhattanShrimp CocktailFilet MignonCreamed SpinachNew York CheesecakeOrderScore$/pt
Bourbon Steak$37$32$79$17$17$18272/100$2.53
Sparks Steak House$31$34$80$18$17$17967/100$2.68
Empire Steak House East 50th$20$34$84$19$15$17270/100$2.45
Strip House$20$27$67$19$16$14974/100$2.01
West Side Steakhouse$17$17$55$8$12$10955/100$1.98

"$/pt" is the cost of the order divided by the score out of 100 — what a point of quality costs. A good dinner at a fair price beats a poor one at a low price.